help me with my christmas shopping...

Screw it all and just get Torino by Cinerama.

actually, despite that being my favourtie of the whole lot. The Bends and Ok Computer are both great albums, and I am slowly coming round to the realisation that the remote part is better than 100 broken windows. That took a long time and a heavy heart to admit.

Just in case anyone forgot that folks here on the forum take this sh*t very, very seriously. (No slam, I'm a full on nut-job, especially to the 'regular people' out in the world blithely getting by with the Counting Crows greatest hits holiday release – not that there's anything wrong with that!!).

Originally posted by mark e smith:
I am slowly coming round to the realisation that the remote part is better than 100 broken windows. That took a long time and a heavy heart to admit.

Originally posted by brennser:

Yes, Steve Wickham has been with Mike Scott from day one.

at the risk of

a) being excessively nitpicky, and

b) incurring the wrath of mankie

thats not true - wickham played on one song from this is the sea and then joined the band on a full time basis…see below


JUNE 1985 Recording for "This Is The Sea" continues in various London studios.

JULY 1985 Gifted Irish fiddler, STEVE WICKHAM plays on a demo for his friend Sinead O'Connor at Karl Wallinger's home studio. Mike Scott hears the tape and invites Steve to play on "The Pan Within" on the nearly completed new album.

No worries about incurring any wrath, I reserve that strictly for morons.

It was a bit nitpciky though…I was in a hurry to get out of here and just trying to make the point Wickham has been with Mike Scott for years.

No worries about incurring any wrath, I reserve that strictly for morons.

and like me, you're probably still in a good mood from Man U's highly efficient 2-0 win over Stuttgart yesterday!

"Room to Roam" is a GREAT Waterboys CD. I highly recommend that one.

Originally posted by brennser:

No worries about incurring any wrath, I reserve that strictly for morons.

and like me, you're probably still in a good mood from Man U's highly efficient 2-0 win over Stuttgart yesterday!

Yes indeed…and this is just about the time of year when United start to pick up their game so you'll see them start pulling away in the premiership now…better get back to music though before we get chastised for hijacking another thread and turning it into footie. ;)

Room to Roam is my personal fave, but would you recommend it to someone looking to get a good example of The Waterboys over the years? By that I simply mean it leans very heavy to the Waterboys in their folk mode so Lily wouldn't hear their more rock oriented work, That's why I suggested Live Adventures because it covers the gammit(sp?).

yeah because they've released just so much stuff over the years I think some type of compilation is best, that way if the person prefers the folky stuff they can go and buy fishermans blues and room to roam, ditto for the big music stuff

I will have to track down a copy of Room to Roam and give it a listen - I never bothered to buy it because it was absolutely panned by all the critics in ireland when it came out first

Originally posted by mankie:
That's why I suggested Live Adventures because it covers the gammit(sp?).

Just think, if you used dictionary.com to look stuff up whenever you didn't know how to spell a word, you might learn more words properly, as well as other meanings of the words and their origins, "gamut" is particularly interesting:

gam·ut ( P ) Pronunciation Key (gmt)
n.
A complete range or extent: a face that expressed a gamut of emotions, from rage to peaceful contentment.
Music. The entire series of recognized notes.

[Middle English, the musical scale, from Medieval Latin gamma ut, low G : gamma, lowest note of the medieval scale (from Greek, gamma. See gamma) + ut, first note of the lowest hexachord (after ut, first word in a Latin hymn to Saint John the Baptist, the initial syllables of successive lines of which were sung to the notes of an ascending scale CDEFGA: Ut queant laxis resonare fibris Mira gestorum famuli tuorum, Solve polluti labii reatum, Sancte Iohannes).]

Are you sure these are the bands that would make the recipients the most happy? Try to find out what gifts would make the recipient the most happy, not just give cd's of bands you like.

I already ended up with a fucking Eric Clapton/BB King collaboration as a gift, and it's not even Xmas yet.

Originally posted by lily1:
peeps..i'm looking to buy 1-2 albums of each artist as gifts and would be keen to know which you think are the best albums. i'd like to avoid buying imports only because i'm really tight on cashola right now. i'd like to get these ordered asap.

idlewild

cinerama

josh rouse

radiohead (anything but httt)

waterboys (i think fisherman's blues is a given but wasn't sure what you thought. mankie, this should be right up your alley)


thanks everyone!

*wonders if this thread will turn from suggestions to debating, once again, if the bends or kid a is the best radiohead album*

Originally posted by Celeste:

Originally posted by mankie:
That's why I suggested Live Adventures because it covers the gammit(sp?).

Just think, if you used dictionary.com to look stuff up whenever you didn't know how to spell a word, you might learn more words properly, as well as other meanings of the words and their origins, "gamut" is particularly interesting:

gam·ut ( P ) Pronunciation Key (gmt)
n.
A complete range or extent: a face that expressed a gamut of emotions, from rage to peaceful contentment.
Music. The entire series of recognized notes.

[Middle English, the musical scale, from Medieval Latin gamma ut, low G : gamma, lowest note of the medieval scale (from Greek, gamma. See gamma) + ut, first note of the lowest hexachord (after ut, first word in a Latin hymn to Saint John the Baptist, the initial syllables of successive lines of which were sung to the notes of an ascending scale CDEFGA: Ut queant laxis resonare fibris Mira gestorum famuli tuorum, Solve polluti labii reatum, Sancte Iohannes).]

I know all the words I need to know to get through life, thank you. For example, "Kiss my arse smart arse" :D

Mind you, if you'd like to come over and be my English teacher…Ms. Celeste ;)

Originally posted by mankie:
Mind you, if you'd like to come over and be my English teacher…Ms. Celeste ;)

How could you let a "doodle" teach an Englishman his own mother tongue? I bet you'd be an incorrigable pupil!

Originally posted by Celeste:

Originally posted by mankie:
Mind you, if you'd like to come over and be my English teacher…Ms. Celeste ;)

How could you let a "doodle" teach an Englishman his own mother tongue? I bet you'd be an incorrigable pupil!

Oh Celeste dear…no interest in the education, just the after school activities! :eek:

fair question–there's a reason behind the particular list–its part of a greater list of concerts i've seen with a particular person who hasn't bought a decent cd in years but really enjoyed the shows listed so i thought, what the hell, i'll get a cd or two from each of the shows (there are a few other concerts but i have either copied those cds or he wasn't totally enthralled by them). good idea?

Originally posted by Rhett Miller:
Are you sure these are the bands that would make the recipients the most happy? Try to find out what gifts would make the recipient the most happy, not just give cd's of bands you like.

I already ended up with a fucking Eric Clapton/BB King collaboration as a gift, and it's not even Xmas yet.

[/QB]

Well when you explain it that way, I'd have to say yes, very good idea.

Originally posted by lily1:
fair question–there's a reason behind the particular list–its part of a greater list of concerts i've seen with a particular person who hasn't bought a decent cd in years but really enjoyed the shows listed so i thought, what the hell, i'll get a cd or two from each of the shows (there are a few other concerts but i have either copied those cds or he wasn't totally enthralled by them). good idea?

Originally posted by Rhett Miller:
Are you sure these are the bands that would make the recipients the most happy? Try to find out what gifts would make the recipient the most happy, not just give cd's of bands you like.

I already ended up with a fucking Eric Clapton/BB King collaboration as a gift, and it's not even Xmas yet.

[/QB]

Excellent idea.