Most believable thing I've read yet.
As a lawyer, it was difficult to listen to the podcast at times, especially the way it was being edited. There's a huge difference between actual guilt and legal guilt and that probably should have been explained more. Either way, all of my theories went out the door when Jay led the cops to her car.
At that point, it was motive of Jay vs motive of Adnan, and frankly, since Adnan had absolutely no alibi, it was hard to fathom it being anyone else.
Do I think the prosecution had enough to go beyond a reasonable doubt? Not with the way this information was presented no, and I could raise serious questions about his attorney's defense, but I wouldn't go that far unless I had read the entire trial proceedings, which, frankly, I'm not going to do. But I definitely think Ms. Gutierrez could have done a better job.
Do I think Adnan killed Hae? Yes, but the job is on the prosecution to put together more evidence than they did (or more than we were presented).
Deidre's well off the mark on this one. She has absolutely nothing to tie Ronald Moore and Jay together. Until then, she needs to look at the real picture and ignore the big picture, which for her is anybody but Adnan.
My favorite part of the podcast was when Adnan got upset about Sarah saying he was such a nice guy that it makes it difficult to believe he could do it. The whole premise of her show was that an attorney contacted her because this really nice kid was convicted of a crime that they just couldn't be he was capable of doing. That doesn't mean shit and he had the exact right response - that doesn't help me one bit, so let's a find a way where I didn't do this with FACT that I can take to the courts. That didn't happen - not even close.
Well, that and where Christina found out Jay's attorney was arranged by the prosecutor and Sarah says "if you or you're loved one is an attorney their mouth is wide open right now" and sure enough, when my fiancee looked over, my mouth was wide open. That was pretty funny.
As a lawyer, it was difficult to listen to the podcast at times, especially the way it was being edited. There's a huge difference between actual guilt and legal guilt and that probably should have been explained more. Either way, all of my theories went out the door when Jay led the cops to her car.
At that point, it was motive of Jay vs motive of Adnan, and frankly, since Adnan had absolutely no alibi, it was hard to fathom it being anyone else.
Do I think the prosecution had enough to go beyond a reasonable doubt? Not with the way this information was presented no, and I could raise serious questions about his attorney's defense, but I wouldn't go that far unless I had read the entire trial proceedings, which, frankly, I'm not going to do. But I definitely think Ms. Gutierrez could have done a better job.
Do I think Adnan killed Hae? Yes, but the job is on the prosecution to put together more evidence than they did (or more than we were presented).
Deidre's well off the mark on this one. She has absolutely nothing to tie Ronald Moore and Jay together. Until then, she needs to look at the real picture and ignore the big picture, which for her is anybody but Adnan.
My favorite part of the podcast was when Adnan got upset about Sarah saying he was such a nice guy that it makes it difficult to believe he could do it. The whole premise of her show was that an attorney contacted her because this really nice kid was convicted of a crime that they just couldn't be he was capable of doing. That doesn't mean shit and he had the exact right response - that doesn't help me one bit, so let's a find a way where I didn't do this with FACT that I can take to the courts. That didn't happen - not even close.
Well, that and where Christina found out Jay's attorney was arranged by the prosecutor and Sarah says "if you or you're loved one is an attorney their mouth is wide open right now" and sure enough, when my fiancee looked over, my mouth was wide open. That was pretty funny.