Big Yawn is a Joke

Originally posted by Celeste:
Originally posted by dulla:
and by glasses i meant the fool on the left in the black shirt
thanks for clarifying, you retard
are you still all pissy and name calling? maybe you need a doggie downer.
doomlink

doomlink

Originally posted by sonickteam2:
Originally posted by Celeste:
Originally posted by dulla:
and by glasses i meant the fool on the left in the black shirt
thanks for clarifying, you retard
are you still all pissy and name calling? maybe you need a doggie downer.
Originally posted by dulla:
the guy with the glasses, he looks like a depressed middle aged yuppie who gets constipated a lot and throws massive fits on the internet.

im just a newbie so dont hate on me for making an observation i dont even know who the guy is


anyway i kind of know the guy who reviewed the album for big yawn, he's a smart guy sometimes
ggw…is that really you?
Rhett's bio
Originally posted by Rhett Miller:
[QB] So when people on the 9:30 Board have a problem with, say, a David Segal review in the Washington Post, they should simply email Mr. Segal with their complaint, and not post their complaint on the 9:30 board?
Originally posted by elj:
[qb]

Well I've been on vacation for a week and havent kept up. I've been reading this thread and can't disagree with what both sides have said so far. But I was waiting for this response for a long time and can't believe it's taken this long to get here. All the bitching about the Washington Post reviews and everyone in the little indie click agreeing with each other of how they don't know what they are talking about and how did they get that job as a reviewer.

Hope you all a had a great holiday season. I still have three more pages to read on this thread. Hopefully noone already said what I said. If so, sorry for saying it twice.
Originally posted by Bombay Chutney:
What if it was the new Muse CD? ;)
I'll review it:

I wasn't thrilled with the cd at all but hearing the same songs live, was very impressed, maybe more than impressed.

Short, sweet and barely to the point, I'm sure.
Originally posted by Celeste:
I like to go to the man in charge. Plus I'm sick of the hot-shot attitude like some folks on here are so in-touch and know so much about music, when you don't know shit. [/QB]
HEY HEY HEY, HOLD ON THERE MISSY!!!!!

When it comes to music I most definately do know shit.

Actually, on the subject of alt-country…there was an article in the Irish Examiner last week trying to educate people on what exactly, "alt-country" is. I got through about 6 words then the attentiion span was gone. ;)
I'm glad this review clears up exactly WHY this album finished 10 places higher than the Drive By Truckers on the BigYawn best of list.

Adam Richman left college at the George Washington University after his freshman year to pursue his dream of being a rock star and getting his musical voice heard. I bet most of us can think of half a dozen people we know personally who have similar stories, but what's really amazing is that Adam Richman is really doing it … and it's paying off. After independently releasing his debut album Two in 2001 and tirelessly touring colleges nationwide for the last three years, Richman is finally seeing his dream come true. After releasing his latest independent album Patience & Science, in which he plays every instrument, sings every vocal track, and produced and recorded everything himself, the world is finally starting to take notice of this young new musical star. He has recently signed on with OR Records and they have re-released a number of tracks from Richman's latest album as The Patience EP, which is the precursor for Richman's upcoming full-length major label debut, to be released sometime early this year.
Hey Rhett, why do you even bother paying attention to what BigYawn has to say if you find so much wrong with it? There are dozens of other music review sites on the internet.
it is the most highly predictable top 50 ever.
Originally posted by econo:
Hey Rhett, why do you even bother paying attention to what BigYawn has to say if you find so much wrong with it? There are dozens of other music review sites on the internet.
I believe he'll say that the constitution gives him the free right to.
I'm a completist when it comes to reading end of year music lists. Isn't everyone?

I will give BY credit. They are the only list to include this Adam Richman dude, even if the review sounds like it was written by a street teamer or close personal friend of Mr. Richman.


Originally posted by econo:
Hey Rhett, why do you even bother paying attention to what BigYawn has to say if you find so much wrong with it? There are dozens of other music review sites on the internet.
True enough, it says nothing about his music.

Originally posted by Rhett Miller:
I will give BY credit. They are the only list to include this Adam Richman dude, even if the review sounds like it was written by a street teamer or close personal friend of Mr. Richman.
One thing that I found interesting to me is how my tastes totally veered from what was popular with critics this year. Typically, there are always a couple of albums universally revered by critics that were also revered by me. Not this year. Anyway, blah blah blah.
There was an album out last year or two years ago by Nada Surf that some of my friends – who have excellent taste – liked but was generally disliked by critics.
Yes, that album is a great makeout/sex album, imo. Most music critics probably don't get that kind of opportunity.

Originally posted by econo:
There was an album out last year or two years ago by Nada Surf that some of my friends – who have excellent taste – liked but was generally disliked by critics.
Originally posted by sonickteam2:
it is the most highly predictable top 50 ever.
?
Everyone pretty much had the same lists this year. (Except for the list I found that included Hillary Duff & Ashlee what's her name Simpson.)
In my opinion '04 wasn't the greatest for new albums, so what did I expect?
Or, like Rhett said, list of albums revered by critics. I actually liked the BY list as it had a few ranks that other lists did not. The top ten wasn't so surprising, but hey, at least the other 40 had a few obscure mentions I'm going to check out.
Originally posted by El Tee:

Everyone pretty much had the same lists this year.
thats what i am saying, blah blah, Fiery Furnaces, TV On the Radio, Franz Ferdinand, Interpol and like a few ones you havent heard of

boring.
Originally posted by sonickteam2:
Originally posted by El Tee:

Everyone pretty much had the same lists this year.
thats what i am saying, blah blah, Fiery Furnaces, TV On the Radio, Franz Ferdinand, Interpol and like a few ones you havent heard of

boring.

I have read at least one that doesnt have any of those on there
leave it to pollard to find anything :)