sweetcell wrote:Space wrote:
Neko Case and Josh Ritter live are boring just like laying on the beach in the Caribbean is boring.
that's quite poetic. nice analogy.
I agree… may have to even steal that as my own.
sweetcell wrote:Space wrote:
Neko Case and Josh Ritter live are boring just like laying on the beach in the Caribbean is boring.
that's quite poetic. nice analogy.
Hutch wrote:
they do put you to sleep…
Yada wrote:Hutch wrote:
they do put you to sleep…
If you found their cds so boring, why did you pay to see them live?
grateful wrote:Again, that's not an apt analogy. Buying a CD vs Stealing it is not the same as "voting." Everyone gets a say in taxes, for example. People should weigh their own self-interests vs the greater good and vote accordingly, I agree.
I've never understood why poor people defend rich people. Its what leads so many to vote against their own economic self interest.
Julian, wrote:grateful wrote:Again, that's not an apt analogy. Buying a CD vs Stealing it is not the same as "voting." Everyone gets a say in taxes, for example. People should weigh their own self-interests vs the greater good and vote accordingly, I agree.
I've never understood why poor people defend rich people. Its what leads so many to vote against their own economic self interest.
Deciding you don't like a business' model and don't care about someone else's intellectual property rights and therefore you are going to steal something is not the same thing. It's not close. The artist "gets a say" because they created it. The label "gets a say" because they put up all the money to record it (in most cases.) The consumer "gets a say" only in the very limited sense of they can purchase it or not. The mental gymnastics people pull off about "the CD model is outdated, therefore I should be able to download it for free" or "I'm sure Ritter would prefer I listen to it for free but attend his concert" (sidenote: I love how many people are mindreaders and know what artists want) is staggering.
Hutch wrote:Yada wrote:Hutch wrote:
they do put you to sleep…
If you found their cds so boring, why did you pay to see them live?
yawn..maybe i heard they were the best songwriters in America at their genre and thought I'd give them a chance…

grateful wrote:Do you actually think that if a business' model is inefficient people should be able to steal from them? "Oh, well, Walmart isn't monetizing Milano cookies to the maximum effect, let's smash in this plate glass window and ransack the place!" Are you actually proposing we just throw intellectual property out the window? I'm sure having no way to monetize software, books, music, movies, etc is going to be super great for us as a society.
The most rabid defenders of intellectual property rights actually don't own any intellectual property.
grateful wrote:The same is true if you could have $10 but 3 million Cambodian children die as a result and you pass on the $10.
your moral high ground doesn't serve your individual interests.
grateful wrote:
Correct.

grateful wrote:
Oh no, it wasn't a compendium of thoughts about intellectual property. My point was that from an economic perspective, your moral high ground doesn't serve your individual interests.
Sidehatch wrote:TIL, serious back and forth = sound and fury.
some serious back and forth although signifying nothing
Julian, wrote:Sidehatch wrote:TIL, serious back and forth = sound and fury.
some serious back and forth although signifying nothing
K8teebug wrote:
I love Neko Case. I saw her with Martha Wainwright at the club and it was one of my favorite shows.